Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
A shameful stalemate

A shameful stalemate

  • 0

Senate Democrats have blocked the Republicans' long-delayed plan for additional coronavirus aid, raising the prospect that Congress will provide no added fiscal support for the economy between now and the presidential election in November. The two sides are no longer talking, and at this point, each might think that doing nothing serves its electoral interests.

Settling for this paralysis, however, would be shameful. The economy needs additional relief immediately; delaying it will only compound challenges down the road.

Republicans’ proposal would extend the existing Paycheck Protection Program (for small employers that retain workers despite losing business because of the pandemic), provide new money for health care and schools, and give financial aid to the U.S. Postal Service. It also proposes a weekly unemployment-benefit supplement of $300 through the end of the year, compared with the $600 bonus in the previous relief package, which ran out at the end of July. Republicans had previously supported a new round of $1,200 stimulus checks as well, but following internal dissent dropped the idea. The overall cost of the proposed measure was between $500 billion and $700 billion — less, if you allow for unspent funds from previous plans.

Senate Democrats have been pressing a version of a measure already passed by the House, which would extend the $600 supplement, give states and cities another $1 trillion in aid, send a new round of stimulus checks, and more, at a cost of around $3.5 trillion. They've said they're willing to trim that back to $2.2 trillion.

But here are the crucial points. States and cities have seen their budgets crunched by higher outlays and lower revenue, and need more financial aid. The unemployed need generous well-targeted help. And the economy as a whole requires additional fiscal support, as the Fed continues to emphasize. Also bear in mind that the cost of additional public borrowing is currently close to zero. This shouldn't license fiscal profligacy, to be sure. But under current circumstances, a new relief measure costing between $2 trillion and $3 trillion (depending on the pace of the recovery) can't be called excessive.

The economy badly needs a compromise plan. The worst outcome would be a tactically motivated stalemate that does nothing at all. Right now, this gross failure of the political process looks all too plausible.

Bloomberg Opinion

Copyright 2020 Tribune Content Agency.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Dothan’s school board will soon embark on a search for a superintendent — again. Dr. Phyllis Edwards issued a letter of resignation last week …

Nancy Pelosi must be supremely confident of a sweeping Democratic victory on Nov. 3. How else to explain why she refuses to compromise on a co…

  • Updated

In the months since the coronavirus pandemic made gatherings dangerous, conclaves of every stripe — from book clubs to corporate briefings to …

This is the time of year that many Alabamians start to think about our state’s superiority. It’s football season, and most Alabamians — even m…

While the Wiregrass area isn’t in the crosshairs, many residents are wisely preparing for the arrival of Hurricane Sally, which is expected to…

As any "Game of Thrones" fan can tell you, the phrase "winter is coming" is not just a House Stark motto but a frequently invoked warning that…

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert